The Pennsylvania Chamber PA Chamber Home Page


House approves key lawsuit abuse reform measure

Chamber members applaud legislative action on ‘apology legislation’

The state House passed legislation (H.B. 495) that would allow health-care providers to apologize to patients without fear of legal repercussions, raising hopes for swift passage of what is known as “apology legislation.” Doing so would be a step in the right direction toward improving the Commonwealth’s health-care climate by reducing costs without compromising the rights of patients. 

The bill would allow health-care providers to speak with patients following an unforeseen outcome without the fear of litigation based solely on the conversation. Specifically, the bill would allow health-care providers to apologize, explain or show compassion or commiseration freely without these statements being permitted as evidence in a court of law. The measure would in no way take away a patient’s ability to sue or pursue other legal action.

The concern that personal injury lawyers will use benevolent gestures or admission of fault against health-care providers and professions sets the stage for the reluctance to have open conversations with patients. As a result, patients are left feeling frustrated and angry, and anger is often a driving force behind medical malpractice lawsuits.

Ensuring that certain statements made by physicians, hospitals or nursing home employees would no longer play a role in lawsuits is a commonsense, consumer and provider friendly approach to lawsuit abuse reform. The measure has a proven track record in other states as a way of reducing the number medical liability claims in the 35 states that employ such practices, according to the Pennsylvania Medical Society, which supports the bill along with other health-care organizations and the PA Chamber.

The bill is part of a comprehensive lawsuit abuse reform package supported by the PA Chamber and more than 50 other business, health-care, local government and insurance associations.

The state Senate must now consider the measure.

Read more about Pennsylvania’s dismal legal climate and the need for lawsuit abuse reform.

###

Founded in 1916, the Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industry is the state's largest broad-based business association, with its membership comprising businesses of all sizes and across all industry sectors. The PA Chamber is The Statewide Voice of Business.

   
Archived articles
Copyright © 2006 Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industry